Alright so time to update this thread. I bought one. 2017 Honda Africa Twin DCT. Was used, got a pretty good deal, came with a bunch of accessories... overall I am very happy. On Sunday rode it for the first time, went to Ned for coffee then up to the top of Mammoth Gulch, was with my brother on his Triumph Tiger 800.
The longer story is I'd been looking for a 2018+ non-Adventure Sport for a while now... drawn in by the more advanced traction & rider modes, also an alleged upgrade to the transmission at very low speeds. But just couldn't seem to find any deals, so was getting into new bike prices. A new bike not so bad, but, knowing I also wanted skid plates, grip heaters, rock bars, panniers, etc. etc. there's probably $2-$3k to spend on a new bike to get it adventure ready, so to speak. But then a guy posted a fairly built up 2017 that was really well maintained, so I nabbed it. Won't name all the differences between the adventure sport & standard model, but the most notable are better suspension and a larger tank with the AS. After sitting on an AS I quickly didn't like either- was too tall and kinda intimidating, compared to the standard mode that seems more friendly. figure they all need new fork seals at some point, so I could just upgrade suspension then, and 220 miles is still a long way to go between stops, if I need more gas I'll bring some in a can. Just didn't like that really wide tank on the AS.
So far I've added case to the rear shelf, Rotopax, and 12v display/usb port to the dash. Also read through the manual, installed some soft bags to the pannier racks that came with it (I also got the hard cases, but trying soft for now), added a Ram mount on the handle bar for my Garmin Inreach, and got gas. it's only been a week.
My first pavement ride experience was pretty awesome... there are basically 4 different automatic modes, from Drive to Sport 1, 2, and 3. Basically 4 different ECT buttons, they just change the shift points for the most part, both up and down. There's also a manual mode where your left finger shifts up and your left thumb shifts down. You can always shift in any gear mode, and no matter what mode you're in you'll be in 1st if you get below 10mph. I settled in on S2 when I was in automatic mode. It handles really well in the twisty turns, Coal Creek Canyon was pretty fun.
First dirt experience was also better than expected. Was worried this was going to feel like a big heavy whale but I was able to control it easily and for the most part pick my lines. I was aiming for the big rocks, wanted to get a feel for how much the suspension absorbs, get comfortable standing, etc. I jumped it once and used pretty much all the suspension landing, and I tagged the skid plate once rolling over a big rock.. definitely not as nimble as the KTM, but we knew it wouldn't be.. but I feel like I could get this over all of Kingston Peak, which is probably as difficult as I'd ever need to take this bike. It's not for single track, but more Weston, Boreas, Rollins pass type of rides. I tested the ABS once, it works, but kinda makes the chain smack the swing arm a lot. I never tested the "G" mode, and never really tested the traction control modes- kept it on the lowest setting the whole time while on dirt. I'll play with that more in the future.
Only other first impressions are just living with a big bike- it's over 8' long and more than 500 pounds, so you really have to be deliberate with where you park, stop, etc. If you park nose down in a tight parking lot you're going to be hosed, there's no way you're going to back up with your toes sitting on the bike. Also no way you're going to pick the back end up. And I'm super glad I never laid it down... I have come close once in the garage putting it on the center stand, and holy cow once it starts tipping it gets soooo heavy. Guess you just get used to that.